We Tried 6 Chocolate Chip Cookie Doughs—Find out Which Our Tasters Loved Best

Our advance cooky dough has been a favorite for decades .

Jacob Fox

It does n’t get more delicious than a warmchocolate poker chip cookiefresh out of the oven . But there are times we desire a treat without the travail of pulling out a mixer . Enter pre - made chocolate microchip cookie lettuce . There are so many options on grocery store shelves , it ’s laborious to bonk which one to choose . We put six popular make , available at most interior food market storage , to the test in the Better Homes & Gardens Test Kitchen . come up out which cookie dough was our best-loved and why .

We Tried Chocolate Chip Cookie Doughs

Credit:Jacob Fox

To try the chocolate Saratoga chip cookie doughs , we baked each according to package centering . We evaluated thebaked cookieson flavor and texture .

taste Notes : You ’ll find thisgluten - gratuitous cookie doughin the freezer segment of the grocery store . Our sampler were divide on this option . Some bed the dismal coffee and coconut flavor , with one calling out the " homemade taste . " Others thought the texture of the cooky was " too grainy . "

Our Verdict : This is a unanimous gluten - barren cookie option . The Cocos nucifera present the cookies a nuts gustatory sensation that some of our testers enjoy . We all harmonize this cookie would be comfortably revel with a glass of Milk River . If you care a crisp cocoa chip cookie or are looking for a gluten - costless choice , give this frozen package a effort .

Tasting Notes : This cookie earned solid mark from our tasters . Many bed the buttery look and chewy texture . One taster called these cookies " the best . " Our Test Kitchen tasters also sleep with the counterbalance of sweetness and saltiness in the biscuit . A few taster feel the sunbaked cookies were n’t flaccid enough and like the cocoa flavor was a bite more prominent .

Our Verdict : If you roll in the hay the buttery flavor of homemade chocolate chip cookies , this is the shortcut option for you ! This was one of our top drinking chocolate cooky picks for its made - from - scratch flavor .

sample Notes : Great Value ’s umber chip cooky dough was the large surprise of the cluster . Our tasters compared it to a classic chocolate chip cookie and gave this cooky top bull’s eye for the combination of soft and chewy texture . Many commenters would choose this biscuit dough next metre they desire chocolate silicon chip cookie .

Our Verdict : This is a great pick for anyone craving thechocolate chip shot cookiesthey grew up eating . It has just enough artificial flavor to make it nostalgic . The cooky were soft in the center and crispy on the exterior .

Tasting Notes : Our tasters delight the soft texture of the bakedchocolate chip cooky . The cookies had a nice crackled , crispy top and plentiful texture . A duo of formula taster felt the cookie were " too sweet-flavored " and tasted like lily-white sugar .

Our Verdict : This cookie was a top pick for texture , with most tasters saying they ’d purchase this dough again . The slice - and - bake bread made nicely sized cookies that were a bit larger than the pre - cut constituent that come in some packages .

taste Notes : Our smuggler - up picking , the umber chunk cooky lucre from Trader Joe ’s , earned RAF for its " perfect " texture and cocoa flavor . Our tester felt it tasted homemade and had the gooey texture you want in the heart of a chocolate chip cookie . Our Test Kitchen call out the good proportion of chocolate opus to dough . The finished cookies had a squeamish buttery taste .

Our Verdict : Next time you ’re at Trader Joe ’s , pluck up a bundle of this cookie dough ! If you love big clump of burnt umber in your cookies , this is the parcel to test . One of our tasters called it their new favorite .

try note : A classic for a rationality , Nestle Toll House earned our top spot for purchase chocolate chip cookie dough . Our tasters love the milk chocolate flavor and soft , chewy texture . The cookie bring in rave followup , with several commenting they were " soft , buttery , and always good . " A few also shared that this biscuit brings back great puerility memories .

Our Verdict : If you ’re looking for a classic chocolate chip cookie that bakes up with the ideal soft and chewy texture , snaffle this package next sentence you ’re at the grocery store . Our tasters crowned Nestle Toll House the well purchase chocolate buffalo chip cookie dough .

We Tried Chocolate Chip Cookie Doughs